| 
Joseph (& the Book of Mormon) | 
Brigham and the Brethrenites | |
| 
The church | 
·  Per D&C 10:67,
  "whosoever repenteth and cometh unto me, the same is my
  church" 
·  Not an earthly
  institution 
·  More a movement and
  collection of like-believing individuals who gathered together with Joseph 
·  In the plural
  referred to groups or congregations of believers | 
·   "Church" referring to "The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints", a trademark
  owned by The Corporation of the President of the Church of Jesus Christ
  of Latter-day Saints (COTPOTCOJCOLDS) 
·   Or: The
  "Brethren" (upper ecclesiastical hierarchy, or "general
  authorities"), that govern the spending of sacred funds, control who
  receives "saving" ordinances, speak at general conference, manage
  church corporations, direct those below them in the hierarchy, receive
  generous compensation, etc. 
·   Or: an earthly
  institution of people who have been baptized by an authorized LDS Aaronic
  priesthood-holding male and confirmed by an authorized LDS Melchizedek
  priesthood-holding male, whose names & private personal data are
  maintained & tracked in a central Church database | 
| 
Offices in the church | 
·  Apostle, Elder,
  Priest, Teacher, Deacon, Member 
·  Did not
  require priesthood (see D&C 20, where it is not mentioned; or JS-H 1:72,
  where Joseph and Oliver were elders after the restoration of the Aaronic
  priesthood) 
·  Were able to
  perform sacred rites outlined in D&C 20 according to the power of the
  Holy Ghost in (i.e., acting through) a person 
·  Later: Bishop,
  Seventy, Patriarch, Historian 
·  Some of the
  apostles were later organized into the Traveling High Council, composed of 12
  apostles, in 1835 | 
·   All but
  "Member" (which is no longer a church office) is conflated with
  requiring priesthood 
·   Many others
  added: High Priest (as part of higher instead of lesser priesthood, as in BoM
  & OT) 
·   Even offices
  changed, for example Brigham swore anyone unmarried or less than mid-twenties
  could never be a Deacon (which matches the New Testament requirement that
  Deacons be married), whereas now Deacons are essentially all 12-year-old boys | 
| 
Presiding Patriarch | 
·  A lineal office in
  the church first filled by Joseph Smith, Sr., then by Hyrum Smith by virtue
  of having received the birthright 
·  Hyrum & Joseph
  being the first (and last) in many generations to be joined to the Fathers via
  the Patriarchal Order/Priesthood (see below) 
·  Office later filled
  by lineage or descent of any descendent deemed "worthy" 
·  Could not be stolen
  by an elected interloper, thereby creating a separation of power within
  church government 
·  Formed an
  independent line of priesthood authority 
·  This line was not
  to be dependent upon selection by temporary office holders drawn from many
  family lines--instead the Smith family, through whom the church was restored,
  would hold this hereditary office forever 
·  Office was intended
  to be succeeded by the officeholder's oldest, direct, descendant, unless
  there was still a living sibling of his upon whom the office would devolve | 
·   An
  interesting office, sometimes used & sometimes not for ordaining the
  office of President of the Church 
·   Title changed
  to "Patriarch to the Church" by Pres. Grant in the 1920's 
·   Sustained as
  "prophet, seer, and revelator" alongside the First Presidency and
  twelve 
·   Most recent
  "Presiding Patriarch" made "emeritus" by the President in
  1979, with no one placed in the office to follow 
·   Last
  "Presiding Patriarch", Eldred G. Smith, passed away in April 2013,
  with the office no longer being filled or deemed necessary by the Church | 
| 
Second Comforter | 
·  Required for
  salvation, redemption, and exaltation 
·  The core of the
  "Doctrine of Christ" spelled out in the D&C, throughout the
  Book of Mormon, and the New Testament 
·  Consistently urged
  by Joseph as what all saints should strive to attain to in
  mortality in order to be able to qualify for the Celestial sphere,
  returning to the presence of the Father | 
·   Not only no
  longer taught as important, but now, per Dallin Oaks, “the suggestion that
  this must happen in mortality is a familiar tactic of the adversary” 
·   Effectively
  abandoned as doctrine until 1960's, then actively rejected by Correlation as
  a topic not permissible for general conference talks, church publications,
  etc. 
·   No longer
  really spoken of at all 
·   More
  important to "follow the prophet", not Christ | 
| 
Book of Mormon | 
·  A guide on how to
  receive the Second Comforter, as shown by authors who actually have traveled
  the path and reached the destination 
·  Text is more pure
  than any other scripture now available 
·  A book of prophecy:
  Events included are ones that typify actual prophesied events in the latter
  days & end times 
·  Isaiah's words are
  central to understanding the entire text 
·  Gentiles are primarily
  the members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, who are roundly
  criticized, condemned, warned & called to repentance by the text | 
·   A moral guide 
·   How "to
  be happy in this life" 
·   How to
  "come unto Christ" in some unspecified, non-literal way 
·   Commonly
  thought to somewhere foretell of a latter-day "Restoration" of a
  New Testament church, this time among the Gentiles 
·   Thought to be
  a witness to the authenticity of the Bible (though the text seems to state
  the opposite) 
·   A tool to get
  people to join the church, using the argument: the Book of Mormon is true,
  therefore Joseph was a prophet, therefore the church is "true",
  therefore we have a "living Prophet" today who has the same keys,
  therefore you need to be baptized 
·   Much more
  palatable as children's cartoons for those that have a hard time with it 
·   Big scholarly
  emphasis on arguing & proving its historicity and on identifying the
  location of events recorded, rather than focusing on uncovering and living its
  message 
·   Inclusion of
  quotes from the Book of Isaiah is annoying and, for some, reason to doubt the
  authenticity of the BoM 
·   Reading is
  something to check off as completed, often requiring business-inspired
  incentive programs (food, rewards, fun trips to water parks, etc.) in order
  to coerce participants to complete their "spiritual feast" on time 
·   Changed
  title, misleading chapter headings, many strange computer-generated &
  linked footnotes | 
| 
Gentiles | 
·  Primarily the
  Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, as spoken of in the Book of
  Mormon and D&C | 
·   Everyone but
  members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the warnings in
  the Book of Mormon being given to those who will never read them but which
  will boost the pride of Latter-day Saints at "not being them" | 
| 
Scripture | 
·  Came regularly by
  translation of ancient records 
·  Came regularly and
  frequently via revelations/oracles 
·  Came regularly by
  Joseph's own hand (letters, LoF in the 1835 D&C) 
·  Expanded &
  extended the saints' understanding 
·  Given by the Holy
  Ghost acting through any person | 
·   Ceased
  completely; no further "thus saith the Lord", except for a couple unpublished
  ones claimed through John Taylor 
·   Changed to
  instead use "official" proclamations, declarations, First Presidency
  statements, general conference talks, press releases, "tweets", and
  Facebook posts | 
| 
Doctrine of the Church | 
·  Published as the
  first part of the 1835 Doctrine & Covenants 
·  Intended to
  elucidate the "Doctrine of Jesus Christ", meaning the Second
  Comforter 
·  Voted in general
  conference by the church to be binding as scripture | 
·   Removed from
  "standard works" by committee in 1923, without any vote from the
  church 
·   Current
  D&C includes only the "Covenants" portion of the 1835 edition
  (and later 19th century editions) 
·   Renamed
  "Lectures on Faith" 
·   No longer
  taught or discussed, including the Second Comforter | 
| 
Nature of God, Godhead | 
(from
  the 1835 D&C, called today the "Lectures on Faith") 
·  "The Father
  [is] a personage of spirit, glory and power: possessing all perfection and
  fulness." 
·  "The Son, who
  was in the bosom of the Father, [is] a personage of tabernacle, made, or
  fashioned like unto man, or being in the form and likeness of man, or,
  rather, man was formed after his likeness, and in his image;--he is also the
  express image and likeness of the personage of the Father: possessing all the
  fulness of the Father, or, the same fulness with the Father; being begotten
  of him" 
·  Holy Spirit: Not a
  personage, but the "Mind of the Father and the Son", which men
  & women must also receive, per LoF 5 
§  "which mind
  is the Holy Spirit, that bears record of the Father and the Son" 
§  "Q. How many personages are there in the Godhead? A. Two: the Father
  and the Son. (5:1.)" 
§  "[the Son]
  possessing the same mind with the Father, which mind is the Holy
  Spirit" 
§  "all those who
  keep his commandments shall grow up from grace to grace, and become heirs of
  the heavenly kingdom, and joint heirs with Jesus Christ; possessing the
  same mind, being transformed into the same image or likeness, even the
  express image of him who fills all in all: being filled with the fulness of
  his glory, and become one in him, even as the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are
  one | 
·   God the
  Father is a male personage with a glorified, resurrected body 
·   The Son is a
  male personage with a glorified, resurrected body 
·   The Holy
  Ghost is a male personage of spirit, not having a body 
From
  the 2013 publication Teaching the Gospel in the Savior's Way: 
There
  are three separate personages in the Godhead: God the Eternal Father; His Son,
  Jesus Christ; and the Holy Ghost (see Articles of Faith 1:1; Acts 7:55–56).
  The Father and the Son have tangible bodies of flesh and bone, and the Holy
  Ghost is a personage of spirit (see D&C 130:22–23). Although the members
  of the Godhead are distinct beings with distinct roles, they are one in
  purpose. They are perfectly united in bringing to pass Heavenly Father’s
  divine plan of salvation. | 
| 
The Holy Ghost | 
·  The Holy Ghost is our own spirit, sanctified and
  connected to the Holy Spirit (the Mind of God) 
·  The Holy Ghost is a personage and an individual. It is a
  Spirit that will dwell inside a person. (D&C
  130:22) 
§  Is the "record of heaven" which lives inside a
  person and that the person lost contact
  with because of the veil. It is a
  personage of spirit who resides inside a person that he or she must
  "receive" after baptism by finally listening to that inner
  "truth of all things" or "record of the Father and the
  Son." (Moses
  6:61, 66) 
§  "In effect, you receive holiness through the
  sanctifying power of the Holy Spirit. This in turn makes your own spirit
  holy. Your spirit or your ghost is within you, connected to heaven to such a
  degree through this process that you
  are in possession of a "holy spirit" or a "holy ghost"
  within you." 
·  "Falls" upon a person as part of an event
  called the "Baptism of Fire and the Holy Ghost", creating a
  permanent, lasting connection 
·  Bears record of the Son. When the Son speaks to a person
  through the Holy Ghost, she or he hears the words in the first-person (thus
  the HG speaking that it "is the Son" in Moses
  5:9) 
·  "The Holy Ghost has no other effect than pure intelligence." (TPJS 149) 
·  Has a different effect on Hebrew vs. Gentile 
§  "It is more powerful in expanding the mind,
  enlightening the understanding, and storing the intellect with present
  knowledge, of a man who is of the literal seed of Abraham, than one that is a
  Gentile, though it may not have half as much visible effect upon the body;
  for as the Holy Ghost falls upon one of the literal seed of Abraham, it is
  calm and serene; and his whole soul and body are only exercised by the pure
  spirit of intelligence; while the effect of the Holy Ghost upon a Gentile, is
  to purge out the old blood, and make him actually of the seed of Abraham. That
  man that has none of the blood of Abraham (naturally) must have a new
  creation by the Holy Ghost. In such a case, there may be more of a powerful
  effect upon the body, and visible to the eye, than upon an Israelite, while
  the Israelite at first might be far before the Gentile in pure
  intelligence." (TPJS 149-150) | 
·   A male spirit
  personage of the Godhead  
·   His influence
  is felt everywhere, although his spirit can only be in one place at a time 
·   Will someday
  have to "get a body", although uncertain how or why 
·   Makes a
  person feel good or "warm all over" when something is right or true 
·   Seen as the
  source of powerful, strong emotions, commonly bringing a person to 'tears as
  evidence of his presence 
·   Even when
  “received” as a gift, is a temporary influence based on our choices | 
| 
Baptism of Fire & the Holy Ghost, or Gift of the Holy Ghost | 
·  Core part of the
  Doctrine of Christ 
·  Controlled &
  given only by the Father (through the Son) directly to a person 
·  Deemed synonymous
  with repentance, baptism of the Spirit, a Mighty Change of Heart, etc. 
·  Accompanied by
  other gifts of the Spirit, including prophecy, tongues, etc. and often by
  interaction with angels 
·  Only Apostles
  touched by Jesus Christ could confer directly (after mighty prayer and at the
  Son's direction) 
§  Per D&C 20
  & BoM 
·  Otherwise came
  directly from God to those qualifying, usually just after baptism though
  sometimes “out of order” before (see Helaman 5) | 
·   Almost
  completely lost core doctrine, despite being plainly laid out (& often
  read) in the Book of Mormon 
·   Taught to be
  an undetectably gradual effect on a person 
·   Apostles play
  no role 
·   Believed by
  most to be immediately bestowed by Elders as part of "confirmation" 
·   Some believe
  the person confirmed is only directed by the elder to do so (as current
  "confirmation" wording suggests), then believing that it somehow
  just comes to most or all members thereafter undetectably 
·   Taught that
  the Holy Ghost is only present when we "do what is right"--not a
  permanent connection | 
| 
Authorization to Institute Rites & Doctrines and to Receive
  Revelations for the church | 
·  The Lord vouched
  specifically for Joseph by revelation in D&C 5:10: "But this
  generation shall have my word through you" 
·  Believed that
  ordinances and doctrines established through Joseph, as "dispensation
  head" should not and could not be altered in the slightest without
  breaking the eternal covenant 
·  The Lord appointed
  Hyrum as replacement prophet to the church in D&C 124, having also been
  elected co-president with Joseph | 
·   From Brigham
  onward, presidents of the church considered the Lord's pronouncements
  regarding Joseph to then be expanded & generalized such that they applied
  to anyone occupying the "seat of Joseph" 
·   Commonly
  believed to permit church presidents to make changes to ordinances and
  doctrines "in the absence of revelation" and that this is why they
  are so important(!) 
·   Hyrum’s role
  as prophet to the Church and president are not acknowledged or honored | 
| 
Prophets | 
·  A gift from God,
  known as having the spirit of prophecy, or as having "received the
  testimony of Jesus" (Revelation 19:10) 
·  Regarded as
  something all saints, male and female, should aspire to
  receive/become--that is, to receive the gift of prophecy. I.e.,
  to receive "the testimony of Jesus" per D&C 76, which is the
  "spirit of prophecy" 
·  Per Numbers 11,
  Moses desired that all his people would become prophets and prophetesses
  ("would that all men were prophets") | 
·   Regarded as
  an office, not a gift from God  
·   Brigham
  Young: “I do not profess to be a Prophet. I never called myself so; but I
  actually believe I am, because people are all the time telling me that I
  am.”  Journal of Discourses, 5:177 
·   Presidents of
  the LDS Church have never claimed themselves to be prophets; it is always
  others that claim such | 
| 
Infallibility | 
·  Considered fallible
  and "only a prophet when speaking as such" 
·  Saints expected to
  confirm truth of his words by the power of the Holy Ghost 
·  Joseph warned repeatedly
  against reliance on a prophet, including sermons on Ezekiel 14 
·  Per Joseph, blind
  obedience to such is "worse than folly to us; it is slavery in the
  extreme" | 
·   Brigham early
  on expressed great fear that saints would blindly follow leaders without confirming
  truth with God 
·   Today:
  Considered effectively infallible 
·   Began with
  Wilford Woodruff's 1898 unscriptural assertion in the manifesto press release:
  "God will not permit me to lead the church astray" 
·   Statement
  resulted from President Woodruff being so criticized by members for the
  Manifesto (abandonment of what was taught to be required for exaltation) that
  he defended himself by claiming that the Lord wouldn't let him make a mistake
  on that order--said that the Lord just wouldn't let the church's president
  lead the saints astray 
·   Any comments
  or opinions are deemed immediately (without question or heavenly
  confirmation) commandments of God, with no possibility of being  
"commandments of men" | 
| 
Status of the President of Church | 
·  An administrative
  and priestly office, a final arbitrator and judge, a presiding authority and
  a leader whose words were to be considered carefully 
·  Elected by the body
  of the church, not appointed 
·  Part of the First
  Presidency, which was equal in authority with the Traveling High Council (the
  Twelve), the Seventies, and Stake High Councils (D&C 107) 
·  Never once selected
  co-presidents or counselors from the Traveling High Council (the Twelve)
  during Joseph's lifetime 
·  Not regarded as
  better/higher, more worthy, more "exaltable", flawless, or
  deserving of accolades & adoration, God being no respecter of
  persons (LoF 3:17) 
·  According to
  D&C 76, not to be adored, "followed", or worshipped--those who do so inherit a Telestial kingdom 
·  According to 2
  Nephi 28:31, such followers of men are cursed ("maketh flesh his
  arm") 
·  Joseph actively
  discouraged and preached against the error of elevating any man above
  another, including and especially himself | 
·   No one but
  Joseph referred to as "the Prophet" until 1955 
·   Since then
  church publications have aggrandized and encouraged adoration of the office
  of President of the Church, referring to the office holder as "the
  Prophet" 
·   Marked
  beginning of Fourth-Phase Mormonism, where adoration of the
  President/Prophet & the Brethren is a central practice, to the point
  of perhaps being the only real remaining “Church doctrine” 
·   Change in
  nomenclature done as a response to the immense unpopularity of Heber Grant
  administration; church members then found it much harder to disregard a
  "prophet of God" without risking damnation, resulting in dramatic
  change in perceptions ("criticism is apostasy") & dramatically
  reducing criticism 
·   Today:
  "Follow the Prophet, Follow the Prophet, Follow the Prophet, Don't go
  astray!" 
·   Declarations of
  the president now considered to be more important than scripture (not
  subject to scripture for validation of truth) 
·   Definition of
  “prophet” now expanded to include all members of Quorum of the Twelve but
  thought not possible to include any lay members of the church 
·   Now commonly
  referred to as our "Beloved Prophet", a term reserved by God only
  for use with his Only Begotten Son, in whom He is well pleased | 
| 
Succession of President of church | 
·  Always done by vote 
·  Not considered as
  needing to be the same as the “prophet to the church”, which was considered
  something that must be received from the Lord by revelation, then consented
  to by the church ("by common consent") 
·  Hyrum was the
  designated successor to Joseph as prophet to and head of the church (D&C
  124) 
·  Had become church
  prophet and Patriarch 
·  Was co-president
  and co-testator with his younger brother, Joseph 
·  Brigham admitted
  Hyrum was to be the successor in the succession debates 
·  But Hyrum fell
  first, as he and his younger brother died martyrs 
·  Many in 1844,
  including Brigham and Sydney, assumed that Joseph III would succeed Joseph
  and that interim leadership would be temporary 
·  (More in "Hyrum
  Smith, Part 2") | 
·   Today:
  Dictated by the articles of incorporation of the corporation sole
  "Corporation of the President of the Church of Jesus Christ of
  Latter-day Saints": most senior member of quorum of twelve is entitled
  to take control immediately on the death of the previous president 
·   Voting by the
  church and ordination are considered as mere outward formalities that take
  place after the fact | 
| 
Aaronic Priesthood | 
·  Never fully laid
  out & explained by Joseph 
·  A brotherhood or
  sisterhood that includes fellowship with angels 
·  Conferred by
  authorized angels/servants ("true messengers"), as portrayed in the
  temple endowment, not by men 
·  Ordination is only
  an invitation to connect with heaven, but is incomplete of itself | 
·   Definitions
  created by men and evolved over time 
§  E.g., at first
  priesthood was believed not to be lost when leaving church, then was decided
  it is lost when leaving church 
§  Although in
  practice, when a man is rebaptized today, he is not ordained again (i.e., his
  priesthood is considered "inactive" after having left the church,
  only needing to be switched back on when rejoining) 
·   Now:
  Something you "hold" (like a sugar cookie) as opposed to something
  you are part of 
§  Can be given by one
  man to another as directed by men who "hold" "keys" 
§  Despite D&C
  121, believed to be controlled by men, including making it
  "inactive" when a person is excommunicated 
§  Line of authority
  concept is considered very important, since God & angels are not directly
  involved | 
| 
Melchizedek Priesthood | 
·  Never fully laid
  out & explained by Joseph 
·  A brotherhood or
  sisterhood that includes fellowship with angels and the person of Jesus
  Christ himself 
·  Conferred by Christ
  himself and not man 
·  Done by Christ
  Himself making an oath to the person after the recipient has been so
  thoroughly proven, that God “will not repent” and remove the authority given
  to the recipient 
·  Not required for
  any church office, including elder, priest, teacher, or deacon. (D&C 20) 
·  No line of
  authority needed; is between a man or woman and God himself 
·  Ordination is only
  an invitation to connect with heaven, but is incomplete by itself | 
·   Because not
  laid out by Joseph, the definitions were created by men and evolved over time 
·   E.g.,
  priesthood not lost when leaving church, then lost when leaving church 
·   Although when
  a man is rebaptized today, he is not ordained again 
·   Now: Received
  when a young man gets approval by a local congregation and some quorum leader
  “confers” this priesthood 
·   Something you
  "hold" (like a sugar cookie) as opposed to something you are part
  of 
·   Can be given
  by one man to another as directed by men who "hold keys" 
·   Can be
  controlled by men, including making it "inactive" when a person is
  excommunicated 
·   Line of
  authority concept deemed very important | 
| 
Fullness of the Priesthood, or Patriarchal Priesthood | 
·  Restored early,
  then lost 
·  A brotherhood or
  sisterhood that includes fellowship with angels, the person of Jesus Christ
  himself, and God the Father himself 
·  Jan 19, 1841: 
·  D&C
  124:28: For there is not a place found on earth that he may come to and
  restore again that which was lost unto you, or which he hath taken away,
  even the fulness of the priesthood [When was this lost fulness restored?
  Where? To whom? How was it brought back? Any records, journals, scripture?] 
·  v. 31-32: But I
  command you, all ye my saints, to build a house unto me; and I grant unto
  you a sufficient time to build a house unto me; and during this time your
  baptisms shall be acceptable unto me. But behold, at the end of this
  appointment your baptisms for your dead shall not be acceptable unto me;
  and if you do not these things at the end of the appointment ye shall be
  rejected as a church, with your dead, saith the Lord your God. 
·  v. 45: And if
  my people will hearken unto my voice, and unto the voice of my servants whom
  I have appointed to lead my people, behold, verily I say unto you, they
  shall not be moved out of their place. | 
·   Later claimed
  as having persisted despite D&C 124, despite incompletion of Nauvoo
  temple, despite being driven from Nauvoo ("moved out of their
  place"), despite no record or evidence whatsoever of its subsequent
  restoration (no revelation, account, journal entries, etc.) 
·   Believed by
  many to somehow be embodied in the temple ordinances 
·   Believed by
  many to be lesser than the Melchizedek Priesthood 
·   E.g., Boyd
  Packer recently taught in general conference that it is just a smaller part
  of the priesthood LDS adult men already have--pertains to being married 
·   Sometimes
  explicitly stated that the church does not have it when quoting D&C
  107:1 | 
| 
Priesthood Keys | 
·  Important knowledge
  required to save a person that is considered part of the mysteries (D&C
  84:19) 
·  Received and
  possessed by a person by virtue of God having given them and man having actually
  done something with it 
·  Is the kind of
  knowledge used to "unlock" understanding ("mysteries") or
  other heavenly gifts 
·  One of several
  things that those of the true priesthood (or order) declare, also including:
  their dispensation, rights, honors, majesty & glory, and power of their
  priesthood (D&C
  128:21) | 
·   Some
  metaphysical, intangible thing that gives the possessor authorization to
  direct the actions of those below him in the church organization's male
  hierarchy (i.e., "authority over" others) 
·   Considered to
  be delegated authority to act & decide in God's place: worthiness,
  eligibility for ordinances that exalt the person 
·   Includes: 
·   Ability to
  direct & control what others do in their assigned duties or church
  assignments ("callings") 
·   Directing
  spending of sacred funds donated by church members 
·   Ability to
  allow people into the church via baptism or forbid such 
·   Ability to
  expel people from the church  
·   Mirrors the
  Catholic tradition 
·   Contradicts
  D&C 121 where such control is forbidden for those with priesthood | 
| 
Priesthood Power | 
·  Authority that
  comes by virtue of true priesthood association/fellowship with the Powers
  of Heaven, the operation of the Holy Ghost through a person, and the
  precise alignment of one's own will with the will of Heaven 
·  Can be forfeited
  instantly and very easily by offending or grieving the Powers of Heaven (per D&C
  121:36-37) | 
·   Available to
  priesthood "holders" who have not committed sins classified as
  serious 
·   Required to
  perform "ordinances" (sacred rites) 
·   Gives the
  "holder" authority to direct others (contrary to D&C
  121:41) | 
| 
Priesthood Ordination | 
·  The giving of an
  authoritative invitation to become part of a heavenly priesthood order, typically
  by one who is already part of that order or fellowship 
·  From the original
  meaning of "ordain": To appoint; to decree 
·  (See Oliver's
  charge to the original Twelve in 1835) | 
·   Now: The act
  of "giving" a male the priesthood, done by one or more men laying
  hands on another and "conferring" the priesthood, then
  "ordaining" to an office "in" the priesthood 
·   For a period
  of 20 years by the direction of President Grant, men were only
  "ordained" to the office in the church/priesthood and
  "conferral" of the priesthood was thought to be implicit | 
| 
Powers of Heaven | 
·  Heavenly beings
  (angels), association with whom is an essential part of ascending back into
  the presence of the Son and then Father | 
·   Completely
  incidental to LDS theology 
·   Levels are
  unknown and unrecognized 
·   Any
  interaction with such is regarded as questionable and likely evidence of
  having been deceived | 
| 
Temple rites | 
·  Apparently
  established in final days of Joseph's life in lieu of restoration of fullness
  of priesthood, as symbolic of the actual process involving
  angels, covenants, etc. in ascending back to the Father, having first
  conversed with the Lord through the veil, and then passing through it 
·  Initiatory (washing
  & anointing) was much more involved: vigorous washing with
  cinnamon-flavored whiskey and anointing by pouring of large amounts of oil
  over heads | 
·   Modified
  immediately after Joseph & Hyrum's deaths with the blood oath to avenge
  them 
·   Later
  modified many, many times by Brigham and others in the absence of
  revelation on the matter. Too many to list, however two recent examples: 
·   In 1991,
  removed penalties, removed the only mortal player (a preacher), and changed
  the final sign. Also revised the lecture at the veil, removing the 5 points
  of fellowship. Done as a result of public polling of saints who were
  uncomfortable with parts of it.  
·   In 2005,
  changed covenant making in endowment to be done in a seated position rather
  than standing 
·   In 2005, changed
  initiatory to be “symbolically” performed, by removing touching of the body
  as part of initiatory. Also, began clothing of initiates with garment of the
  priesthood before washing & anointing, then doing so
  “symbolically” afterward. | 
| 
Baptisms for the Dead | 
·  Consisted only of
  baptism for some specific dead: 
·  Those personally
  known to the one doing the ordinance as someone who would have accepted the
  truth had they been permitted to tarry, and they could bear personal
  testimony of the character of the deceased 
·  Those persons who
  left a record from which it could be judged they would have accepted the
  truth had they tarried 
o The same standard as the
  first category, but the evaluation is based on their written record, rather
  than the personal knowledge 
·  Those who, by
  revelation, are known to be willing to accept the truth had they tarried 
·  Were only permitted
  to be performed outside the Nauvoo temple for a short time 
·  If the Nauvoo
  temple was not completed in the allotted time, the saints would be
  "moved out of their place" (D&C
  124:45) and "[their] baptisms for [their] dead shall not be
  acceptable unto me; and if you do not these things at the end of the
  appointment ye shall be rejected as a church, with your dead, saith the Lord
  your God." (D&C
  124:32) | 
·   Evolved into
  the modern practice of indiscriminate performance of ordinances for everyone
  deceased, even those who were known to have rejected the gospel of Jesus
  Christ outright or whose character was known to be ungodly | 
| 
Temple garments | 
·  Temple garment
  created as a single piece of linen, from ankles to neck to wrists 
·  Marks made during
  Initiatory by making cuts into the cloth ("cutting" a covenant, as
  "making a covenant" literally translates to in Hebrew)  
·  Not worn 24x7 
·  After crossing the
  river headed to Carthage where he would be martyred, Joseph directed that
  those who had received the rites in the red brick store destroy their
  garments | 
·   Altered for
  convenience of saints (as a result of their complaints of inconvenience),
  raising bottom to knees, splitting across the middle into two garments (not
  one; possibly unintentionally imitating the results of the second penalty),
  raising sleeves to shoulder, dropping neckline significantly, changing
  fabrics, and disallowing homemade garments | 
| 
Commandments | 
·  Directions given by
  the Lord's own voice directly to a person 
·  Not given as
  demands but by invitation & persuasion, easily ignorable 
·  Directions given by
  the Lord through an authorized servant by revelation, particularly as
  received by Joseph as dispensation head or as recorded in scripture | 
·   Some of the
  commandments given by the Lord in former days (as deemed still desirable),
  and  
·   Ever-growing
  list of outward rules, guidelines, and checklists introduced by church leaders
  from Brigham up to the present which must be abided by in order to have
  access to the power of God they are believed to control—“commandments of men” 
·   Includes
  things like how many earrings are appropriate, what color dress shirts should
  be worn by young men, a required part in the hair of male missionaries,
  payment of "tithing" for temple entry, etc. 
·   Hard to
  forget, because of how often they are repeated, checked, and measured | 
| 
Obedience | 
·  Expected by God to His
  commandments only (see definition of "commandments" above) | 
·   Expected by
  the Brethren to their own commandments, traditions, and preferences,
  which are commonly taken to be the measure of a person's "sustaining the
  brethren" in their callings 
·   Many
  formalized and distilled in the "Church Handbook of Instructions",
  a corporate policy manual 
·   Often
  measured and tracked using business-like indicators and reports  
·   Many such
  "commandments" & traditions are, by definition, specific to
  conservative US culture, regularly exhibiting Utah-specific quirks, such as veneration
  of pioneers and reenactment of the divine curses they greatly suffered under
  (“trek”) | 
| 
Apostles | 
·  Ordained as
  directed by God through revelation 
·  Charged by Oliver
  Cowdery in 1835 that their "ordination [was] not complete" until revived
  under hand of God himself 
·  Charged with
  teaching & baptizing throughout the world | 
·   A church
  office, appointed by the President of the Church & perfunctorily approved
  by church vote of "common consent" 
·   No longer
  charged with "completing one's ordination" by having God himself
  lay hands on the man (since Reed Smoot in 1900) 
·   No longer any
  evidence of being chosen by revelation 
·   Emphasis on
  managerial skills, worldly financial security, amount of tithing paid, &
  business acumen 
·   Derived
  almost exclusively from the proud posterity of Nauvoo-era saints | 
| 
Mysteries | 
·  Joseph encouraged
  saints to seek out the mysteries, including receiving angels (or
  "servants", as they are most often referred to in the scriptures) 
·  Taught to heed Book
  of Mormon counsel & direction to seek out the mysteries.  
·  1 Nephi 10:19:
  "For he that diligently seeketh shall find; and the mysteries of God
  shall be unfolded unto them, by the power of the Holy Ghost, as well in these
  times as in times of old, and as well in times of old as in times to come;
  wherefore, the course of the Lord is one eternal round." | 
·   Actively
  discouraged and frowned upon 
·   “I have come
  to believe also that it is not wise to continually talk of unusual spiritual
  experiences.” (Ensign, January, 1983) | 
| 
Angels | 
·  Key part of the
  Plan of Redemption, who, as "servants", help prepare a person to
  receive the person of Jesus Christ (the Second Comforter). 
·  Per the Book of
  Mormon, are received by those of a "firm mind". (Moroni 7:30) 
·  Key part of path to
  Christ & salvation, as demonstrated in the lives of Saul, Joseph, Alma,
  Moses, Peter, Mary, Elizabeth, Agabus, and John. | 
·   Any such
  accounts looked on with high suspicion of having been deceived (a
  reaction I directly observed in the mission field) 
·   Hugh Nibley's
  description of his grandfather, a member of the First Presidency, who said
  that if he ever saw an angel he would "jump out the window." | 
| 
Miracles | 
·  Speaking in
  tongues, miraculous healings, even raising from the dead were not uncommon 
·  Were the primary
  motivation for many joining the church (not the First Vision account or the Book
  of Mormon) | 
·   Almost
  unheard of today and rarely discussed when they do happen 
·   An
  uncomfortable topic when they rarely do occur 
·   Members
  prefer they happen at a distance--in time or space--or not at all 
·   In
  fulfillment of 2 Nephi 28:
  5-6 | 
| 
Prophesying | 
·  A gift from God
  ("prophet") 
·  Something accepted
  as normal and encouraged 
·  A gift highly
  sought after | 
·   Now: No
  prophecy ever given by the Brethren 
·   First
  Presidency and Twelve are sustained & voted to be "prophets",
  despite no evidence of such a gift 
·   Frowned upon
  by members of the Church and considered problematic 
·   Alternative
  reliance on scholars and scholarly approaches to finding "wisdom" | 
| 
Seership | 
·  A gift from God ("seer")
  that is greater than prophecy 
·  Possession &
  use of seer stones by Joseph 
·  Also possessed and
  used by some other members | 
·   Now: First
  Presidency and Twelve are sustained & voted to be "seers",
  despite no evidence of such a gift 
·   Seer stones still
  possessed and used by some into early Utah era (e.g., locating a stolen cow,
  etc.) 
·   No longer
  claimed to be used for "seeing"/scrying | 
| 
Revelations | 
·  A gift from God
  ("revelator") 
·  Joseph produced
  many revelations, given as spoken by God in the first person | 
·   Now: No
  revelations given by the Brethren 
·   First
  Presidency and Twelve are sustained & voted to be "revelators",
  despite no evidence of such a gift 
·   Policy
  changes often spoken of in private as "revelations" or received via
  a "revelatory process" 
·   1978 granting
  of priesthood to Blacks 
·   Proclamation
  on the Family (Boyd Packer referred to it as revelation in general conference
  only to have the written transcript changed to remove the designation later) 
·   2012 change
  in age for missionary service | 
| 
Translation of ancient records | 
·  A gift from God
  ("translator") 
·  Done regularly by
  Joseph: Book of Mormon, New & Old Testaments, Book of Abraham | 
·   No additional
  translation of any ancient records, even when requested & given
  opportunity | 
| 
Ordinances | 
·  Considered to be
  unchangeable from what was given through Joseph 
·  Part of the
  covenant from God that must be remembered and not broken | 
·   Deemed
  changeable as desired and "in the absence of revelation" by the
  Brethren, with neither explanation required nor vote from the body of the
  church needed | 
| 
Sacrament | 
·  Wine used, although
  "it mattereth not" was permitted 
·  An apostle or elder
  blessed, administered, and "passed" it, per the pattern in D&C
  20:38,40,46,50 and 3 Nephi
  18:3-9, with the oldest priest covering only
  if an apostle or elder were absent  
·  Person offering
  prayer knelt and prayed with uplifted hands 
·  Congregation knelt while
  prayer offered 
·  Generous portions
  of bread & wine used ("until filled"), as in a meal 
·  Single cup used for
  the wine | 
·   Wine
  continued to be used through the late 1800's 
·   Church
  established wineries in Southern Utah that served congregations in Idaho,
  Utah, and Arizona 
·   Now: Water
  used 
·   Wording of both
  ordinance's prayers changed: “hath”
  instead of “had” in the first, and “water” instead of "wine" in the
  second 
·   Administered
  ("passed") by teachers and deacons, who are forbidden from
  participating in
  D&C 20:58 
·   Person
  praying is only person kneeling, usually with hands clasped low or arms
  folded 
·   Congregation
  does not kneel 
·   Tiny pieces
  of bread used to optimize distribution for large congregations 
·   Many small,
  disposable plastic cups used for water | 
| 
Common Consent | 
·  Voting in both the
  affirmative and negative for church offices was normal an acceptable, often
  even involving friendly discussion about it before a vote was taken 
·  Was no concept of a
  "retro-active" vote to sustain "ordaining" of someone to
  a church office | 
·   Voting in
  meetings to "sustain" people in church offices is, in practice,
  purely a formality: members are strongly expected to vote in the affirmative 
·   Negative
  votes are almost completely unheard of 
·   Normal
  procedure for negative votes purportedly is to ignore it and then have a
  "leader" confront the negative voter in private after the meeting
  to determine if there is some reason that they can deem valid for the
  person's objection 
·   Negative
  votes commonly result in punishment, such as removal of temple recommends,
  etc. 
·   Social morays
  in this area are very strong, where objecting to a proposed officer would be
  perceived as "not sustaining" one's leaders 
·   "Priesthood"
  ordination is regularly done in advance of a vote by the church 
·   As of October
  2014, sustaining is now expected to be taken as "an oath-like
  indication" of fealty to the president of the Church | 
| 
Meetinghouses | 
·  No meetinghouses
  built or used for meetings, except for Kirtland temple 
·  Meetings held in
  the homes of the people or outdoors 
·  Nauvoo's
  "bowery" was according to the original definition of the word
  ("a shady place; a natural shady or leafy shelter in a wood or
  garden"), not the later definition as used in Utah settlements. (the
  first structure put up in a new community in order to have a temporary place
  for worship and other kinds of meetings, including school, until permanent
  facilities could be built)  See here
  for more details. | 
·   Built
  everywhere, often extremely luxurious, ornate, and expensive, in fulfillment
  of 2
  Nephi 28:13 
·   Build
  according to protestant standards, including elaborate & impressive
  sounding pipe organs, elevated seats for "leaders", crosses (at
  least in 19th century LDS churches), etc. | 
| 
Church Meetings | 
·  No formal structure
  to meetings, but conducted by "the workings of the Spirit, and by the
  power of the Holy Ghost … whether to preach, or to exhort, or to pray, or to
  supplicate, or to sing" "according to the commandments and
  revelations of God" (Moroni 6:9) 
·  Informal, smaller
  gatherings where the sacrament was partaken of (most often, during the week) 
·  Not structured in
  advance 
·  Preaching done from
  the scriptures, as moved upon by the Holy Ghost | 
·   Highly
  structured, business-like meetings, identical in form from one week to the
  next. Include formal agendas, printed and distributed to attendees 
·   Church
  officers presiding are always seated on an elevated stand in specific seats
  of honor and acknowledged as such 
·   Speakers
  stand at an elevated stand having a microphone that loudly projects his or
  her voice to attendees, commonly with two spotlights trained on the pulpit to
  provide added luster, stage presence, and overall effect 
·   Conducted
  according to strict structure and list of rules, as dictated by the “Church
  Handbook of Instructions” 
·   Topics,
  order, who is involved, and music are all carefully determined in advance by
  the deliberation of the ward bishopric (sometimes delegated entirely to a
  single person) 
·   Formalization
  of each program is normally put into printed form so the arriving congregation
  knows exactly what will happen in advance 
·   Preaching
  often done by reading or summarizing as a basis, in fulfillment of Isaiah’s
  portrayal (Isaiah 29:13) | 
| 
Sabbath Observance | 
·  Weekday activities
  set aside to allow the person to wholly focus on the Lord 
·  No checklists used
  and no required Sunday meeting attendance | 
·   Expected
  attendance at block meetings in order to be considered "active"; "inactive"
  members are considered in spiritual peril 
·   Professional
  business attire for men (suit, tie, leather shoes) and fancy dress (jewelry,
  shoes) for women is expected as necessary in order to properly worship and
  reverence God 
·   "Reverence"
  is preeminent in meetings, which is used to mean: silence and obedience to
  superiors, particularly among children, where it is commonly enforced or
  coerced through use of candies 
·   Extremely
  rigid schedule and elements in meetings, with often quite repetitive wording
  and business-like agendas  | 
| 
Calling | 
·  A person's work to
  perform, as revealed by God Himself to the person | 
·   An assignment
  in the church, whether scriptural or not, to be performed according to Church
  Handbook of Instructions (CHI) rules & procedures and as directed by
  those holding "keys" 
·   Repeatedly
  taught to be something to accept without question to show proper deference to
  and “faith” in leaders 
·   Formerly
  referred to as a "office", though "office" now refers to
  a male's "place within the priesthood" | 
| 
Tithing | 
·  Established by the
  Lord (D&C 119) after the saints failed to live the United Order 
·  Those joining the
  church gave one tenth of all their possessions at the time they joined (paid
  in kind) 
·  Then gave one tenth
  of their surplus, or profit, at the end of each year
  thereafter (paid in kind) 
·  I.e., after
  obligations & necessities had been taken care of | 
·   Members are
  taught to pay one tenth of their gross income 
·   I.e., before
  taxes and anything else 
·   "Do you
  want gross blessings or net blessings?" 
·   Members
  taught to do so even if it means not having enough to buy food for their
  families 
·   "Full
  tithe" payment is a requirement for entry into the temple, which members
  believe is the only place they can access essential "saving"
  ordinances that give them access to the highest blessings of God | 
| 
Word of Wisdom | 
·  Explicitly stated
  by the Lord not to be "by commandment or by constraint" 
·  As given to Joseph
  in D&C 89, actually allows for beer (v. 17) and wine (v. 5), among other
  things 
·  Hot drinks being
  understood to mean either very hot in temperature, or the same as
  "strong drinks": distilled alcoholic drinks like whiskey, vodka,
  gin, etc. 
·  Joseph having
  regularly enjoyed wine (as the night before his murder) and beer (see original,
  unredacted DHC, June 1, 1844 entry) | 
·   Is a
  requirement (a "constraint") for baptism or entry to the temple 
·   Is now
  interpreted as meaning all alcohol in any amount is forbidden (began
  in 1920's, during Prohibition) 
·   "Hot
  drinks" now changed to mean coffee and tea and, commonly, anything
  having caffeine 
·   Meat is no
  longer considered something that need be used "sparingly", the
  saints commonly participating in "meat-loving" American culture, despite
  Lorenzo Snow teaching this as the most critical part | 
| 
Polygamy | 
·  Something Joseph
  Smith very actively, very vocally, and publicly decried and fought against in
  Nauvoo 
·  Had multiple people
  brought before the Nauvoo high council to be tried for attempting to practice
  & teach polygamy 
·  In the 1835
  D&C, voted to be considered scripture by the church, it included a
  since-removed section 101 declaring polygamy to be a whoredom 
·  The Book of Mormon
  equating polygamy to a whoredom 
·  Joseph’s journal
  entries noting his public preaching against polygamy later doctored &
  rewritten to portray him preaching in favor of it, as now revealed in JS
  Papers 
·  Joseph’s private
  practice of sealing women and men to himself later being altered in the
  historical record to suggest marriage, though DNA testing now confirms that no
  lines of offspring from sexual relations resulted  | 
·   Practiced
  broadly & publicly in latter-half of 1800's starting with Brigham Young 
·   Considered an
  absolute requirement for exaltation 
·   Practiced
  with goal of producing children (though Brigham only had 51 with his 55
  wives) 
·   Begun in the
  absence of revelation "to the Lord's people" 
·   Included practice
  of Brigham Young openly taking still-married women from their husbands,
  sealing them to himself, and then fathering children by them 
·   Discontinued
  at turn of century as a direct result of governmental pressure and without
  any recorded revelation 
·   Then
  considered an excommunicable offense 
·   Still
  believed & taught by modern Mormons to be a true principle | 
| 
Temple Sealings | 
·  Only performed by
  the Prophet Joseph, though not in a temple 
·  Promise of eternal
  union based on conditions 
·  Must be sealed by
  the Holy Spirit of Promise, which was in Joseph (but not controlled by men) 
·  Performed after a
  couple had been married for some time | 
·   Performed by
  any "sealer" whom the First Presidency or Quorum of the Twelve have
  delegated "keys" to (are "authorized") 
·   Regarded by
  most church members as automatically guaranteeing eternal union 
·   Was
  "families can be together forever", now is "families are
  forever" 
·   Considered
  shameful or disgraceful when a sealing does not happen at the same time as a
  couple's wedding | 
| 
Sealing Power | 
·  A gift from God
  only entrusted to his most loyal children (Helaman
  10:5-10; D&C 132:47), allowing
  the person, in precise accordance with God's will, both to bind on earth and
  in heaven 
·  Given only directly
  by the mouth of the Lord himself to the person, pronounced in the presence of
  the angelic hosts of heaven | 
·   A power
  handed from one man down to another, effectively fully delegated to men on
  earth to manage & control (per 2 Nephi 28:5) 
·   Believed to be
  governed, directed, and controlled by the President of the Church 
·   Once believed
  to only be useable by the President of the Church, now believed to be
  "delegatable" two levels: to the twelve and from them again to
  "sealers" in temples, but such that it cannot be given again to
  others without permission from the President of the Church | 
| 
Sealing | 
·  A sacred rite where
  a person is "sealed" to a Father, such as our dispensation head
  (Joseph) by that person, having received the sealing power from the mouth of
  God himself in the presence of the angelic hosts of heaven 
·  Apparently permits
  the "sealer" to "bring" those sealed to him with him on
  the fiery ascent back through the heavens to where God dwells 
·  Also related to
  bringing the "children" back into a covenantal relationship with
  "the Fathers", such that they can be redeemed by virtue of the
  relationship with a "vassal king" 
·  Not used to
  link a person to his/her unsaved dead ancestors, who are not in heaven
  but remain unexalted in the Spirit World instead | 
·   Once in Utah,
  the practice until the late 1800's was to "seal" people to the
  dispensation head (known as "Law of Adoption"), Joseph, not to each
  other or genealogical lines 
·   Now: a rite
  used to "seal" or link a person to his/her spouse, children, or
  dead, unsaved ancestors in the Spirit World, performed by one holding delegated,
  corporate-directed LDS sealing power (see above), only available to persons
  conforming to modern Mormon evolved definitions of tithing and the Word of
  Wisdom | 
| 
Marriage | 
·  Always performed in
  public according to direction in section 101 of the 1835 edition of the
  D&C (removed sinc) 
·  Considered a
  "sacrament", thus marriage feasts included consumption of alcoholic
  wine (as in John 2 and D&C 89:5) | 
·   Removed
  section 101 in 1835 edition from D&C when plural marriage began being
  publicly practiced in Utah to allow for privacy of plural marriages from
  suspected government spies 
·   Now: Normally
  takes place in private within temples where only adults deemed
  "worthy" are permitted 
·   All members
  taught from childhood they should settle for nothing less and allow no one
  "unworthy" to do so | 
| 
Black/Negro Race | 
·  Not taught to be regarded
  as any different than any other "race" of man, Joseph Smith having campaigned
  for the liberation of black slaves by payment of “owners”, which would have
  prevented the American civil war 
·  Black males
  ordained to priesthood, like Elijah Abel | 
·   Deemed &
  taught, starting with Brigham Young, as descendants of Cain and unable,
  therefore, to obtain priesthood in this life, having been unvaliant in the
  life heretofore 
·   Decided in
  the absence of any recorded revelation 
·   Both male AND
  female blacks denied all temple ordinances deemed essential to eternal life,
  not permitting initiatory, endowments, or eternal marriage | 
| 
Prayer Circle / True Order of Prayer | 
·  Practiced in both
  homes and in temples 
·  Was expectation of
  divine manifestations when practiced | 
·   Long taught
  to patrons in temples, so the instructions could be followed privately in
  homes, in ward and stake leadership meetings (meetinghouses not uncommonly
  having had altars in special rooms for this purpose), etc. 
·   Banned from
  practice in homes & meetinghouses in 1978 by Spencer Kimball, thereafter
  only temple ordinance workers being permitted to perform it within temples 
·   Unclear why temple
  goers are still instructed in how to do so at all since it is not a permitted
  practice | 
| 
The Remnant / Lamanites | 
·  A group of
  descendants of Lehi desperately sought in order to preach to them the
  "fulness of the gospel" 
·  First people
  missionaries were directed to find 
·  Search continued
  despite US government's attempts to block, clear up until Joseph &
  Hyrum's deaths 
·  Expected to be
  found in the "Rocky Mountains" 
·  Regarded as the
  group that will build the earthly New Jerusalem, allowing for the heavenly
  City of Enoch to return as part of the Second Coming (3 Nephi 21:22-24) 
·  Expected to be
  "assisted" by "a few" Gentiles that repent | 
·   An
  interesting historical footnote no longer relevant to the progress of
  "the kingdom of God" | 
| 
The United States | 
·   The Lord's
  nation, which will serve as a vehicle to save other nations 
·   Its existence
  will "hang by a thread" only to be rescued by the Church and
  proceed to some glorious, nebulous role in ushering in the millennium | |
| 
Church Discipline | 
·  Always locally
  conducted 
·  Only available
  penalty was excommunication (removal from the congregation) 
·  Conducted according
  to strict guidelines given in the revelations of D&C (D&C 20:80, 42)
  and the Book of Mormon (Alma 42:15-22), including requiring: 
·  Offended parties to
  first approach the offender and attempt to be reconciled before bringing the
  matter before church authorities 
·  Multiple witnesses
  of known integrity to bring forth the accusation of the unrepented offense 
·  Restrictions on the
  origin of information that may be used for any trial 
·  Use of Elder's
  Courts in advance of high council hearings 
·  Defenders of the
  accused in every case, but not a requirement for prosecutors 
·  Multiple levels of
  appeals and rehearings to address the possibility of biased or erroneous
  judgment 
·  Measures preventing
  judges from rendering verdicts without majority agreement from a high council 
·  Measures preventing
  an accuser from sitting in judgment against the accused 
·  The accused and
  their defenders to always be granted the last word, so any true words of
  defense of the innocent will ring out over the words of accusation 
·  Involving the
  congregation with excommunication (vote of agreement, public rebuke before
  them, etc.)  | 
·   Now:  
·   Conducted
  according to continually changing, often vague guidelines in the secret
  corporate guidebook (CHI Vol. 1) 
·   Can result in
  varying levels of penalties including informal probation, formal probation,
  "disfellowshipment", and excommunication 
·   Uses
  different public vs. private definitions for apostasy 
·   Great
  latitude taken by stake presidents regarding following even the CHI
  instructions 
·   Normally
  initiated by a leader after a private confession of a member, thought to be
  part of reconciling oneself with God (no other witnesses as accusers) 
·   Commonly
  initiated or conducted by local leaders as directed by general authorities,
  including coming to conclusions as directed 
·   Commonly put
  the stake president in the role of plaintiff/accuser, detective, prosecution,
  defense, witness, jury, and judge, compromising any possibility of fairness
  by eliminating all checks and balances 
·   Regularly
  excommunicate for purported apostasy without telling the accused what he or
  she has allegedly incorrectly taught 
·   Vote taken by
  the high council has no bearing on the decision but is merely symbolic and
  seen as a demonstration of loyalty to the stake president's decision 
·   Elder's
  Courts are completely unknown 
·   Proceedings
  of councils resulting in excommunication are kept secret, allowing
  non-participants always to suppose that "there must be more to the
  story" whenever a claim is made of unjust accusation or judgment | 
| 
Zion | 
·  A Terrestrial
  society of those able to withstand the presence of Christ himself (having
  already individually received the Second Comforter) 
·  Do not suffer to
  have any poor among them 
·  Are of "one
  heart & one mind", as a result of "possessing the same mind
  with the Father, which mind is the Holy Spirit" (LoF 5:2)  
·  Also referred to as
  the "f of God on the Earth", required to be in place in order for
  the "Kingdom of Heaven" to return (D&C
  65:6) 
·  As a city, to be
  established in the "tops of the mountains", not in a valley 
·  Believed to be destined
  for the Rocky Mountains 
·  To be primarily
  Lamanites with some repentant Gentiles (3
  Nephi 21:22-24) | 
·   Now: A
  synonym for the church as a whole, where "all is well!" 
·   Historically
  (per Brigham and successors), Utah 
·   Also,
  historically, the Lord's Bank 
·   Somehow
  different than the New Jerusalem  (despite the 10th Article of Faith) | 
| 
Kingdom of God | 
·  According to
  Christ: 
·  Is not of this
  world--not an earthly, Telestial kingdom (John 18:36) 
·  Cannot be observed
  by mortal man (Luke 17:20) 
·  Is within you (Luke
  17:21) 
·  Must be "set
  up on earth" in order for the Lord and "Zion above" to descend
  (D&C 65:5) 
·  Is intended to be a
  kingdom of kingdoms, with a King of kings and Lord of lords, as hinted at in
  the LDS Endowment 
o Men and women are
  intended to rise up, enter into God's presence, and made "kings and
  queens, priests and priestesses" to Him 
o Just as Joseph and Emma
  were made a king and queen in the presence of the Council of 50, after Joseph
  turned the church over to Hyrum to be its president, Hyrum having replaced
  Joseph as the church's head (D&C 124 
·    | 
·   Evolving
  meaning: 
·   The Council
  of 50 (referred to in shorthand as "the kingdom") 
·   In the 19th
  century, an earthly, political kingdom, under the
  presidency/reign/governorship of Brigham Young and those governed by him 
o Brigham having had
  himself made an earthly king by the Council of 50 
·   In the 20th
  century, the LDS Church | 
| 
Role of Women | 
·  Considered by the
  Lord to be very important 
·  As evidenced by
  women being the first to receive the Second Comforter and the twelve being
  chastised for not believing their report 
·  Considered to be
  destined to become part of a matriarchal priesthood as part of her ascent 
·  Prophetesses
  regarded as normal and expected anciently (Miriam, Elizabeth, Anna) and in
  modern times (Eliza Snow) 
Commonly
  laid hands on other women and children to heal by their faith in the Lord | 
·   Now: May hold
  certain positions in the church, and do as directed by priesthood superiors 
·   Relief
  Society no longer has autonomy organizationally and financially 
·   Not even
  permitted to hold church offices not believed to "require
  priesthood", such as Sunday school presidencies | 
| 
Personal Testimony | 
·  An inner spiritual
  witness of truth received from God by the Holy Ghost 
·  Results from
  earnestly seeking truth 
·  Requires asking,
  seeking, knocking 
·  Given on the Lord's
  time, not man's | 
·   A conviction
  to be gained by repetitively stating something is true before audiences,
  thereby conditioning the mind to accept and believe whatever is presented is,
  in actuality, true 
·   This
  technique used particularly with those preparing to serve proselytizing
  missions for the Church who may harbor doubts or who may lack what they feel
  is sufficient knowledge of what they will be daily claiming to others is true 
·   Sometimes
  alternately taught that it comes from reading the scriptures and other
  literature and then praying to God about it | 
| 
Repentance, Confession, & Forgiveness | 
·  Repentance is simply turning away from the sin &
  confessing to God (D&C 58:43) 
·  Confession to God is required, directly and in private,
  for all sins, then, when asked for forgiveness, He forgives almost all sins
  immediately (D&C
  64:3-7) 
·  If applicable, confession is further required only to
  the "offended party" (person), in private, who has been
  offended, hurt, or damaged by our sins (D&C
  42:88,92) 
·  Public confession required, if public sin (e.g., Alma,
  Jr.) 
·  Not forgiving confessed sins brings condemnation to the
  offended party (D&C
  42:88; D&C
  64:8-11; D&C
  98:39-40; D&C
  82:1) 
·  Only when a sinner refuses to repent, offering no
  confession of guilt to the party offended, are the ecclesiastical authorities
  to be informed of the sin 
·  Considered innocent until proven guilty 
·  Requires testimonies of 2 or more bona fide witnesses,
  having personal knowledge of the unrepented sins in question, 2 of which must
  be trustworthy LDS 
·  Must know sin is not confessed & not forsaken 
·  Confession of repented sins to
  ecclesiastical leaders unscriptural and therefore was not practiced | 
·   Repentance is a multi-step "process" that takes
  some time 
·   Confession is expected to a ward's bishop for sexual
  sins, lapses with the Word of Wisdom, serious crimes, and abortion, whether
  the person has confessed them to the Lord or not 
·   Believed that the Lord cannot forgive a person of these
  unless and until they are first confessed to a bishop 
·   The bishop determines what the person must do to
  "sufficiently" repent and when he or she can be forgiven and is thus
  believed to be able to control who can receive forgiveness from the Lord 
·   Sometimes teach there is a distinction between the Lord
  forgiving a person and "the Church" doing so | 
Monday, July 18, 2016
Joseph vs. Brigham and the Brethrenites
The following is a short sampling of contrasts between what Joseph Smith taught & practiced (including what the Book of Mormon and D&C teach) versus Brigham and his successors' alterations, adjustments, removals, replacements, modifications, additions, and evolutions. It does not attempt to be a comprehensive list by any means and does not present more than just a few references. The reader is encouraged to study the topics out for herself or himself, reviewing newly available historical records and scriptures. Also, as a caveat, the middle column, in particular, represents only a limited snapshot in time of some of the author's understanding and is expected to change as his understanding of the gospel and Mormon history expands. The author expects some minor fixes to the article may be made due to unintentional errors or incomplete thoughts by the author.
 
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
 
 
I just stumbled on this post...thank you for producing this very telling and informative juxtaposition of beliefs. Every gospel stone seems to reveal a different story than the one we've been taught when over-turned.
ReplyDeleteThis is a tremendous breakdown. Thank you for making it. I have to admit I laughed out loud at the "sugar cookie" reference.
ReplyDeleteI still had Daymon Smith's humorous comments rattling around in my head when I added that parenthetical. (see https://daymonsmith.wordpress.com/2013/12/16/racing-to-erase-race/)
DeleteIt's a good parenthetical. ;)
Delete